Watch CBS News

TV experts offer Emmy predictions

Emmy will dispense her favors Sunday night when the 67th Emmy Awards airs at 8 p.m. EDT Fox.

In the meantime, TV's biggest guessing game moves into high gear, with its players including two sure-of-themselves Associated Press television critics.

Will "Modern Family" continue its best-comedy streak? They say: Yes and no.

Will "Mad Men" finish its run by picking up another best-drama statuette? They say: Maybe, maybe not.

Now here's the full list of confident yet often clashing forecasts from those fearless prophets for seven major Emmy races:

DRAMA SERIES:

LYNN ELBER

Should win: "Mad Men." It ended as intelligently as it began, so true to its brand of storytelling that even Coke would be envious.

Will win: "Game of Thrones." The superbly produced saga is that rare bird, a fantasy with sufficient heft to gain Emmy respect.

FRAZIER MOORE

Should win: "The Americans." It's downright un-American it's been overlooked again.

Will win: "Mad Men." This was a grand finale season for the series that, along with "The Sopranos," certified a golden renaissance in drama on television.

---

COMEDY SERIES:

ELBER

Should win: "Transparent." Riding a wave of social change isn't the trick. Making art of it, with heart, is what should make this a winner.

Will win: "Veep." The political winds are at its back after four solid seasons on the campaign trail, and Emmy voters will reward consistency.

MOORE

Should win: "Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt." Fresh, funny and wickedly uplifting. What a welcome treat!

Will win: "Modern Family." This has become such a habit with Emmy judges they're in danger of contracting Repetitive Stress Syndrome.

---

ACTOR, DRAMA SERIES:

ELBER

Should win: Jon Hamm, "Mad Men." Did we ever not believe he was Don Draper, from the highs to the lows? Don't hate him because he's matinee-idol handsome, Emmy voters.

Will win: Jon Hamm, "Mad Men." Spoiler Bryan Cranston of "Breaking Bad" is gone, removing the only legit reason Emmy voters had to bypass Hamm's work.

MOORE

Should win: Jon Hamm, "Mad Men." He should win, even if his competition this year weren't largely unimpressive.

Will win: Jon Hamm, "Mad Men." Emmy won't squander its last chance to correct this glaring sin of omission.

---

ACTRESS, DRAMA SERIES:

ELBER

Should win: Taraji P. Henson, "Empire." Her virtuoso acting turn feeds the show's soap opera spirit without making a cartoon Cookie.

Will win: Viola Davis, "How to Get Away With Murder." The two-time Oscar nominee (to Henson's one) is a gift to TV, and Emmy will show its gratitude for her take-no-prisoners performance.

MOORE

Should win: Tatiana Maslany, "Orphan Black." A crowd by herself in so many roles on this supernatural clone-fest she's lost count of them all, Maslany supersizes the accomplishment of acting.

Will win: Taraji P. Henson, "Empire." An exciting performance on the series that proved that, even in an age when cable and streaming video routinely steal the show, a broadcast network can still launch an empire.

---

ACTOR, COMEDY SERIES:

ELBER

Should win: Jeffrey Tambor, "Transparent." His unerringly thoughtful performance and the zeitgeist are both on his side.

Will win: Jeffrey Tambor. A respected journeyman actor gets the starring role he deserves and the acclaim his performance demands.

MOORE

Should win: Jeffrey Tambor, "Transparent." Much more than comic, Tambor's nuanced performance as a man's late-in-life transition into a woman is not only perfect, but perfect for this moment.

Will win: Jeffrey Tambor, "Transparent." Why not? Nominated but never awarded for past classic characters, he has outdone himself here and he will be recognized for it.

---

ACTRESS, COMEDY SERIES:

ELBER

Should win: Lily Tomlin, "Grace and Frankie." Her sly performance both grounds and elevates the high-concept comedy.

Will win: Julia Louis-Dreyfus, "Veep." An Emmy favorite (and deservedly so) from "Seinfeld" to "The New Adventures of Old Christine" to "Veep," happy habits are hard to break.

MOORE

Should win: Amy Schumer, "Inside Amy Schumer." An arresting, exciting and original comedy voice everyone was waiting for without even realizing.

Will win: Julia Louis-Dreyfus, "Veep." Good at what she does, and comfortably familiar doing it, she'll be the comfortable choice for the fourth time in a row.

---

LIMITED SERIES:

ELBER

Should win: "American Crime." An unsparing dissection of crime and punishment, and widely available on a broadcast network, ABC, not premium cable. A winner on both counts.

Will win: "Olive Kitteridge." The adaptation of Elizabeth Strout's Pulitzer Prize-winning novel honored its pedigree, and Emmy voters appreciate breeding.

MOORE

Should win: "American Crime." It was ambitious, heartbreaking and illuminating. But a win for the splendid "Olive Kitteridge," "Wolf Hall" or "The Honorable Woman" would do Emmy just as proud.

Will win: "American Horror Story: Freak Show." Its rival series - all superior but not nearly so high-profile - will cancel one another out, clinching a win for this popular, much-buzzed-out freak show.

View the full list of 2015 Emmy Award winners.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.